HomeAway Adopts Expedia’s “Verified Reviews” Methodology

The one constant when it comes to HomeAway’s property listings has been consistent change. Since “Best Match” launched in Fall 2015, HomeAway/VRBO changes have been difficult to track. The latest round of changes will affect guest reviews, guest service, and sort order which will reduce the number of guest reviews allowed up to 30%. Some HomeAway customers are already experiencing a negative impact on their rental bookings.   

Recently, Expedia added HomeAway’s Vacation Rentals to their product portfolio, which is likely why HomeAway adopted Expedia’s “Verified Review” methodology earlier this year. Now only guests that made a booking on HomeAway can leave a review. Since TurnKey began, 30-40% of bookings received a review on HomeAway/VRBO. Now only 10% of stays receive a review on HomeAway/VRBO.

How Does This Guest Review Reduction Work?

Only the guest that booked can leave a review: Prior to the change, other guests who had stayed at the vacation rental could leave a review. TurnKey would prompt guests that use the WiFi to review the property. Now that practice is not possible.

Why HomeAway Has Made This Change?

TurnKey believes HomeAway is interested in ensuring reviews are legitimate—a very worthwhile pursuit. Some property managers blatantly promote fake reviews. However, we believe those to be several bad actors in isolated instances.

How This Change Can Negatively Impact Vacation Rental Bookings

In the fragmented vacation rentals marketplace, bookings to each property come in from many different sites.


Booking Source HomeAway Other Listing Sites
Number of Bookings/year 20 20
Number of Reviews 2 4
Review Rate 10% 20%

For instance, what if the average home has 40 bookings/year and the source for 50% of bookings is HomeAway. Imagine the 10% review rate we’re seeing applied to this example, there would only be 2 reviews on the average property per year.

The Expedia “Verified Reviews” methodology makes sense for hotels. One hotel with 100 rooms would have 100X times the opportunity to receive reviews from verified guests compared to vacation rentals.

How TurnKey Will Continue to Work Acquire Reviews for You

TurnKey will shift focus to generate reviews directly on www.turnkeyvr.com and continue to offer robust check-out communications to encourage reviews on HomeAway by the primary booker. We will implement effective review tools to reach all guests that stay in our vacation rentals. We are confident that our standard of 30-40% review rate for all states will return.


Print Friendly, PDF & Email


TurnKey Homeowner Offers Free Place to Stay to Nashville First-Responder

2 Min Read May 4, 2020

TurnKey Homeowners Help Provide Local Housing for COVID-19 Front-Line Responders

1 Min Read April 10, 2020

TurnKey Vacation Rentals Secures Another $48M in Funding

2 Min Read July 23, 2019
TurnKey Blog